Let me start off by saying that I was always a big fan of the series. I have the original animated movie on DVD, and I watched the original cartoon, Beast Wars, and the other shows when I was a kid. When the first Transformers movie came out a few years back, I didn't mind it. I thought it was a very entertaining movie and did the original series justice. Some people loved it, others hated it. Whatever, everyone is entitled to their opinions. However, let me just say that as an aspiring computer animator, these movies are amazing. The first movie was a little intense with the special effects, but the second movie wasn't as overwhelming for some reason. The animation and graphics in this movie were incredible and really left me amazed. I know the amount of time it took to make the graphics and animation, so it is really impressive.
When it comes to this movie, I was very entertained. That does not make it a good movie, it merely makes it an entertaining movie. There are good movies like Gran Torino and the Curious Case of Brad Pitt that are meant to convey emotions and make you connect with the movie. Then there are entertaining movies that are meant to keep you distracted with special effects and explosions and leave you going "that was kickass." Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen was the latter. It left me insanely entertained from beginning to end and I thought it was awesome. Movie critics don't appreciate these kinds of movies. They want acting and a compelling plot, not giant robots fights of good vs. evil. That's why reviewers gave this movie shit ratings. If you want emotions and acting, go watch some Jennifer Aniston movie. If you want to be entertained for 2 and a half hours, watch Transformers.
The premise of the story is that Sam is the child of destiny to help bring an end to the war between Autobots and Decepticons. The Decepticons come back with force and try to start some ancient machine to destroy the sun. The one thing I noticed right off the bat with this movie is the addition of new Transformers and the increase in dialogue of these characters. The first movie was much more about the human characters and their interactions. The sequel had more involvement with robots than it did humans. This is not saying it is bad thing. I was hoping there were be newer Transformers and make it more interesting, and for the most part, there were. I really liked the "old Transformer" that was brought back to life, and I liked the premise that they were on Earth for thousands of years. Many movies have had the premise that aliens helped humans build their societies, so it was interesting to see how it played in the Transformers universe. As far as the premise of Optimus dying and being brought back to life to destroy the enemy made more sense than you know. In one of the Transformers shows from years back, there was a story that had the exact same premise. Optimus dies, and the Matrix brought him back to life, so I can't really hate the story.
As far as the human actors go, they were ok. I love John Torturro, so I was glad to see him back in this movie. As for Shia LeBouf's character, the whole idea of him being this destiny child was a little farfetched, but he had to be the center of the story somehow. His was acting was the same as it normally was, decent but not great. Megan Fox had to just stand there and look hot and she would do her job. Her acting isn't as good as any other actress, but she is hot, so I guess it works out. The parents parts in these movie seemed a little out of place. They were good for a few chuckles in the beginning of the movie, but it didn't really seem to fit with everything else. As far as Sam's roommate in the movie was concerned, he was completely unnecessary. He was the comic relief and that's all he was good for. He really didn't need to be in as much of the story as he was. He could have been in the beginning for a few reaction shots and then he could have been done away with. He was the same as those "Twin Autobots," who were really not necessary at all. Plus Tom Kenny, the voice of Spongebob, also did voices for a couple of characters in this movie, which turned the characters into really silly ones. His voice is really obvious, so I really couldn't take the movie seriously when those characters were on.
Let me just say that this movie was really cheesy, but that's honestly what I expected. Transformers was never really was supposed to be this high-quality movie like The Dark Knight. Characters and series like Batman are much more complex and go into a much more emotional and psychological level than the Transformers series. Transformers were always just about looking cool and fighting each other. That's it. Keep that in mind when you watch this movie.
As far as the dvd quality goes, it was good. The video is breathtaking in Blu Ray and the audio matches that. Everyone really should start using Blu Ray, because it is amazing. The really wasn't much in terms of Extras here. All that was there was a commentary from Michael Bay and a few other people that I really didn't care enough to listen the whole way through. Michael Bay really isn't the most interesting director, so it didn't seem worth it to be honest. He's good at blowing shit up, but I didn't really want to hear how he did it. I'm assuming the 2-Disc Special Edition DVD has all the good stuff, but I would have liked to see maybe one other extra on here, like a behind the scenes thing. Just something else to make it seem this DVD was worth it. Oh well...
This DVD was decent. The movie was good, and the video and audio were top notch. The extras were lacking, so I'm not sure this Blu Ray is worth the 30 dollars you would ultimately pay for it. If I were you, I'd spend the few extra dollars and get the Special Edition, because I've heard there are a lot of kickass extras on there.
I'm going to give this dvd an 8.2
The 2-Disc Special Edition gets a 9.2
This is, of course, if you like this sort of thing. If not, then enjoy watching The Proposal.